The Merlin Award has never been without controversy.
Some years the same award is presented several times to different people:
- ‘Close Up Magician of the Year 2010′ went to both Eugene Burger and Tse Tow Joon Yeen
- ‘Female Magician of the Year 2008′ went to Scarlett, Arian Black and Bambi Van Burch (Correction by Tony Hassini. Despite her promotional material, Scarlett received ‘Female Illusionist of the Year’).
- ‘Illusionist of the Decade’ went to Luis deMatos 2010, Joe Labero 2009, and Franz Harary in 2004. (Correction by Tony Hassini. Luis DeMatos got 2010-2020, Franz got 2000-2010, Joe Labero got ‘Master Showman of the Decade’).
At other times there are categories which seem extremely similar:
- 2008 – ‘Fastest Quick Change Act in the World’/'Best Quick Change Act for 2008′
- 2008 – ‘Magician of the Year’/'Best Magician in the World’
- 2008 – ‘Best Stage Magician’/'Best International Stage Magician’.
But one controversy that stands above the rest is that of Bambi VanBurch.
Her husband Kirby VanBurch – Prince of Magic, had already won Merlin Awards for ‘Magician of the Year’ 1999 and ‘Entertainer of the Year’ 2001, and he in 2007 he received ‘Entertainer of the Year’ while Bambi was presented ‘Female Magician of the Year’ based on the illusions she was performing in the duo’s show.
In 2008, Bambi was again awarded ‘Female Magician of the Year’ – as was Arian Black and Scarlett – Princess of Magic. (Correction, Scarlett got ‘Female Illusionist of the Year’).
In 2009 Bambi branched out with a solo show as ‘Bambi VanBurch – Princess of Magic, and was awarded ‘Female Magician of the Decade’. The presentation took place on June 8 and the mayor of Branson declared it ‘Bambi VanBurch day’. Kirby was also present according to this press report.
In this video clip she talks about her husband being her main teacher, and her upcoming solo show.
In August Kirby posted press releases that the two were separating due to “irreconcilable differences” and the long process of divorce began.
Shortly after that, a letter from Tony Hassini, President of the IMS appeared on Bambi VanBurch’s website. After some investigation Kirby said it was put up without his knowledge by a member of his staff. This letter stated that Mr Hassini had written to Kirby in June telling him that Bambi was copying other magicians presentations and must stop, and as she hadn’t, she would be stripped of her 2007 and 2008 Merlin Awards.
It also said that she must stop calling herself ‘Female Magician of the Decade’ as the title was never awarded to her by the IMS.
Speaking to iTricks Kirby said this was correct as his request to Tony to award her the Decade title was turned down.
- Page 1 of the two page letter can be viewed here – or you can see the text of page 1 at the end of this article.
- Mr Hassini granted her the award in a letter in February, then denied it existed in a letter in October.
- Kirby said she didn’t get the award, the picture “must be doctored”, yet reports say he was present at the ceremony.
- Mr Hassini was revoking her awards because she was using copied material in her show, despite the fact that other Merlin Award winners do too.
- The Oct 21 letter implies that, in June, Kirby reassured Mr Hassini that Bambi was not using copied material, yet here Kirby claims Bambi was warned against using copied material, and she continued using it regardless. Yet sources say he created her show for her.
Dear Kirby and Bambi,
We have enjoyed a long standing friendship over the years and because of this, it
is with heartfelt regrets that I must inform you of my decision to revoke and
rescind all titles and honors bestowed upon Bambi VanBurch as a recipient of the
Merlin Award for the years 2007 & 2008.
The Merlin Award is one of the most prestigious honors in the world of magic.
The award was created to recognize and distinguish the best-of-the-best in the art
of prestidigitation. A recipient is judged on performance, originality, skill, ethics,
and outstanding contributions within the magician’s society.
Merlin Award recipients are required to maintain the highest level of integrity,
ethics and industry standards so as not to bring shame and disgrace upon the
Merlin Award, the image and prestige of the Merlin Award and the past and future
recipients of the Merlin Award.
In June of 2009,1 contacted Kirby with my concerns about complaints and reports
we had received from magicians that Bambi was plagiarizing the illusions and
materials of other well established magicians without their authorization. At that
time, I was assured that this was not the case and because of our long term
relationship, I had no reason not to believe you.
I now have proof that she was in fact performing proprietary material of others
without performance rights. In particular, I am referring to Steve Wyrick’s “Stack
of Trunks Appearance”, David Copperfield’s “Princess Without A Middle”, David
Copperfield’s “Chicken & Duck Head Exchange”, David Copperfield’s “Slow
Motion Duck”, David Copperfield’s “Duck Cannon”, and David Copperfield’s
“Millennium Cabinet”. Additionally, I believe that she also inappropriately used
the music and patter of others.
I have also learned that Bambi is promoting herself as “Female Magician Of The
Decade” as well as “Female Magician Of The Year” for the year 2009. Bambi can